Scythe Power Dials vs Cardboard Trackers: Upgrade Guide
By Stonemaier Games | Published: 2026-10-28
Category: Comparisons
Compare the official Scythe Power Dials with the cardboard trackers from the core game. Learn which upgrade fits your play style and budget.
Quick Answer
If you play Scythe with more than two players frequently and want a more tactile, durable tracking method, the Scythe Power Dials are a worthwhile upgrade. For occasional solo or two-player games, the included cardboard trackers work fine—save your money.
Why the Upgrade Matters
The core Scythe game includes two cardboard power trackers, which are sufficient because only two players engage in combat at a time. However, if you regularly play with three to five players, you'll need a way to track power for each faction. The official Power Dials offer a more robust solution that can replace the cardboard trackers entirely.
Cardboard trackers are functional but can wear over time, especially with frequent play. The Power Dials are designed to be more durable and provide a clearer, more satisfying interaction when adjusting power levels.
Compatibility and Coverage
The Scythe Power Dials set includes dials for the Crimea, Saxony, Rusviet, Albion, and Togawa factions. If you own expansions with additional factions, you'll need to check compatibility—the set covers the base game factions only.
Remember, the dials are an accessory, not a required component. The core game already includes two power dials, so the upgrade is about convenience and consistency across all players.
Trade-Offs at a Glance
- Durability: Power Dials are more robust than cardboard trackers, which can bend or wear with heavy use. If you play often, the dials will last longer. Consider how many plays per year you expect; if it's more than a dozen, the dials are worth it.
- Cost: At $6.90 (compared to $10.00), the Power Dials are an affordable accessory. However, if you rarely play with more than two players, the cost is unnecessary. Weigh the price against how often you'll actually use all five dials.
- Tactile Experience: Dials offer a satisfying click when adjusting power, enhancing the game feel. Cardboard trackers are functional but less engaging. If game feel matters to you, the dials are a clear upgrade.
Product Facts
- Scythe Power Dials (set of 5): This pack of 5 power dials (used for combat in Scythe) includes dials for the Crimea, Saxony, Rusviet, Albion, and Togawa factions. If you play with these five base factions, you can replace the cardboard trackers for all players, ensuring everyone has the same tactile experience.
Scythe Power Dials (set of 5) - Scythe Power Dials (set of 5): These power dials are not needed to play Scythe, as the core game includes 2 power dials, and only 2 players at a time can participate in combat. For solo or two-player games, the included dials are sufficient, so the upgrade is optional unless you want a uniform set.
Who Should Upgrade?
Best for
- Groups that regularly play Scythe with 3-5 players and want a consistent tracking method.
- Players who value component durability and a more tactile game experience.
Not for
- Solo or two-player gamers who are satisfied with the included cardboard trackers.
- Budget-conscious buyers who prefer to spend on expansions rather than accessories.
